If you've ever stopped to watch rain falling on a windowpane, you've seen what happens when two drops of water touch and merge into one. But you probably never imagined that the physics at work in this phenomenon was the key to unlocking a solution for the development of miniaturized personal biological analysis devices. An international team of scientists from IBM Research - Zurich and the Microfluidics for Oncology Laboratory at Polytechnique Montréal made this remarkable discovery, and recently published the results of their work in Nature.
Installing a lab on a chip: a longstanding challenge
For the past 20 years or so, research conducted around the world into so-called lab-on-a-chip devices has shown promise for the perfecting of portable tools that would require only a sample of bodily fluid (e.g., blood, saliva, urine) to screen for diseases or measure biological data. These kinds of miniature systems already exist for simple measurements made with few reagents: glucose meters and pregnancy tests are two examples. But when it comes to more complex analyses, which require mixing a single sample with a series of reagents in precise quantities and a specific order, researchers have been slow to deliver on the promise.
One of the most promising approaches for integrating multiple reagents into one testing device is to deposit picolitre-sized droplets (a few billionths of a millilitre) into a microsystem, using a technique analogous to inkjet printing, and then sealing the device. On contact with air, the tiny quantities of liquid evaporate instantly, leaving a very precise sequence of dried reagents, which can be rehydrated when the fluid sample is added at the time of the test. A major difficulty has persisted, however: when the fluid moves across the dried reagents, it disperses them, "scrambling the signal" and preventing execution of delicate diagnostic steps that involve precise biochemical measurements.
A solution revealed by a phenomenon never studied until now
To attack the dispersion problem, researchers Onur Gökçe, Yuksel Temiz and Emmanuel Delamarche of IBM Research - Zurich hit upon the idea of stretching a water drop into a long ribbon-like shape in a microchannel the width of a human hair, and forcing the liquid to fold over onto itself. In doing so, the water sample closes up in a manner similar to a zipper being fastened.
"This very intriguing process allows us to reduce, to the minimum, the flow rate of the liquid locally, where the dried reagents are, so that when the reagents are rehydrated, they no longer disperse," explains Emmanuel Delamarche, Manager of the Precision Diagnostics group at IBM Research - Zurich.
While the results observed were conclusive, the team still had to fully understand the fluid dynamics phenomenon at work--it had never before been studied--and then control it so that it could be exploited as part of a reliable process. Professor Thomas Gervais, head of the Microfluidics for Oncology Laboratory at Polytechnique, tackled that part of the project.
From experimentation to modelling
By further studying the behaviour of the water drop, the researchers concluded that it was related to the phenomenon of coalescence, one example of which is seen in the spontaneous merging of two drops of a liquid that come into contact with each other. In physics terms, coalescence originates from the strong affinity between water molecules, the effect of which is to reduce the surface of water exposed to the air to a minimum. That's why tiny water drops are spherical: of all geometric shapes, the sphere is the one with the smallest surface area for a given volume.
"In this case, however, we had to study what happens when a water droplet distorted in a microchannel coalesces with another part of itself," Professor Gervais explains. "Our goal was to understand the phenomenon and control it, so that we could force the liquid to stagnate at the precise spot where it meets a reagent inside the device."
Modelling of the phenomenon, which the team dubbed "self-coalescence," was based on a mathematical approach developed in the 1950s to study unbounded two-dimensional viscous flows. The work was performed using calculation techniques developed by Samuel Castonguay, who is completing his PhD in engineering physics at Polytechnique under Professor Gervais's direction. To harmonize the modelling results with the experimental results, Mr. Castonguay went to Zurich, working for a few months with the IBM researchers.
"Not only have our models enabled us to master this new type of flow, but we can also very precisely program spatial and temporal configurations of chemical signals using a combination of reagents, with minimal dispersion, and with no need for user intervention," Professor Gervais notes. "The partnership between our two teams has therefore given birth to a novel, particularly flexible and precise biochemical testing architecture, which preserves the usage sequence of dozens of reagents simultaneously during a test."
Toward targeted mobile diagnostic tools
The IBM team also demonstrated that this type of architecture could be used to measure enzymatic reactions, with an eye to detecting various diseases (genetic illnesses, for example). It also showed a proof-of-concept for a method of DNA amplification (a reaction used to produce copies of a specific DNA segment from a sample) at ambient temperature. The method eliminates the need for a technician to perform repeated heating and cooling cycles on the sample. A single sample droplet is inserted into the device, and analysis is performed automatically. This experiment shows potential for future use of the process to perform DNA sequencing of genes associated with pathologies such as cancer, and to detect certain viruses.
"Our hope is that our process will enable lab-on-a-chip manufacturers to achieve unprecedented diagnostic performance, with products that are as simple to use as today's glucose meters," Dr. Delamarche says.
Lastly, given that the biochemical signals recorded by this type of test could likely be read by a smartphone and transmitted to a centralized databank, the tests could also play an important future role in monitoring the spread of epidemics in remote regions far from medical centres, and in national- and international-level screening for various diseases.
Self-coalescing flows in microfluidics for pulse-shaped delivery of reagents
Onur Gökçe, Samuel Castonguay, Yuksel Temiz, Thomas Gervais & Emmanuel Delamarche
Nature volume 574, pages 228–232 (2019)
Associate Professor in Department of Engineering Physics at Polytechnique Montréal
Phone: (514) 340-4711
Manager of the Precision Diagnostics group at IBM Research - Zurich